• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Parker Scheer

Experienced Trial Attorneys

FREE CONSULTATION – 7 DAYS A WEEK
MA: (617) 886-0500


NH: (603) 507-6627


NY: (212) 897-2223

  • Home
  • Attorneys
    • Eric J. Parker
    • Barry Scheer
    • Susan Bourque
    • Heather Boutet
    • Lawrence “Lonnie” Murray
    • Amanda M. Frederick
    • Shannon MacDonald
    • Legal Support Staff
      • Amanda Benjamin
      • Nicole J. Hadaya
      • Emma Farhart
  • About Us
    • Reviews
    • Case Results
    • In The News
    • Blog
  • Our Practice
    • Personal Injury Lawyer
      • Medical Malpractice
      • Car Accident Lawyer
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Rideshare Accident Lawyer
      • Dog Bite Lawyer
      • Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
      • Nursing Home Abuse
      • Birth Injuries
      • Burn Injury Lawyers
      • Construction Site Accidents
      • Negligent Security
      • Injuries from Wooden Porch or Deck Collapse
      • Product Liability
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • MBTA Accidents
      • Wrongful Death Attorney
      • Food Poisoning
      • Sexual Harassment
      • Aviation Injuries
      • Slip and Fall Accidents
    • Business Litigation
    • Employment Law
  • Contact Us
Call
Contact
Blog
  • Home
  • Attorneys
    • Eric J. Parker
    • Barry Scheer
    • Susan Bourque
    • Heather Boutet
    • Lawrence “Lonnie” Murray
    • Amanda M. Frederick
    • Shannon MacDonald
    • Legal Support Staff
      • Amanda Benjamin
      • Nicole J. Hadaya
      • Emma Farhart
  • About Us
    • Reviews
    • Case Results
    • In The News
    • Blog
  • Our Practice
    • Personal Injury Lawyer
      • Medical Malpractice
      • Car Accident Lawyer
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Rideshare Accident Lawyer
      • Dog Bite Lawyer
      • Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
      • Nursing Home Abuse
      • Birth Injuries
      • Burn Injury Lawyers
      • Construction Site Accidents
      • Negligent Security
      • Injuries from Wooden Porch or Deck Collapse
      • Product Liability
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • MBTA Accidents
      • Wrongful Death Attorney
      • Food Poisoning
      • Sexual Harassment
      • Aviation Injuries
      • Slip and Fall Accidents
    • Business Litigation
    • Employment Law
  • Contact Us

17 Nov 2026

My Car Made Me Do It! Can You Blame an Accident on Driver-Assistance Technology?

Imagine driving down the highway when your car suddenly slams on the brakes for no apparent reason, or jerks the wheel to avoid a hazard that isn’t there. For you and your passengers, it is terrifying. For the car or cyclist behind you, it can be catastrophic. This type of scenario is becoming increasingly common as more and more vehicles have electronic driver-assistance features.

As Consumer Reports notes, modern driving has become a collaborative effort between humans and vehicle computers: done right, it makes roads safer; done wrong, it introduces entirely new dangers.

Most importantly, driver assistance does not mean driver replacement. Regardless of how sophisticated these systems get, we are not yet in the era of truly self-driving personal vehicles. Drivers must remain attentive, maintain control of their vehicles, and be prepared to intervene when necessary. Relying on technology is not an excuse for abdicating that responsibility.

But what happens when the technology itself contributes to an accident? Can a driver simply blame the car? And could the vehicle manufacturer also be held responsible?

The answers may be more complicated than you think.

Quick Answer: Can You Blame an Accident on Driver-Assistance Technology?

Not necessarily. Drivers using advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS) remain responsible for operating their vehicles safely, even when automated features are activated. However, if defective technology contributes to a collision, the vehicle manufacturer may also bear responsibility. Determining who is liable requires examining both the driver’s actions and electronic evidence from the vehicle.

Key Takeaways

  • Driver assistance is not self-driving. Most ADAS, including Tesla’s Autopilot, require drivers to remain attentive and prepared to take control.
  • Technology designed to prevent accidents can sometimes contribute to them. Unexpected braking, steering corrections, and failures to recognize hazards can create dangerous situations.
  • Overreliance on automation can make drivers less attentive. Drivers who assume their vehicles can handle every situation may not react quickly enough when something goes wrong.
  • Both the driver and vehicle manufacturer may bear responsibility for a crash. When defective technology contributes to an accident, a product liability claim may be possible in addition to a negligence claim against the driver.
  • Electronic evidence can be critical to establishing fault. Vehicle data can help investigators determine whether driver error, a technological failure, or both contributed to a collision.

What Are Advanced Driver-Assistance Systems (ADAS)?

Today’s vehicles are equipped with increasingly sophisticated technology called ADAS and if you’re in the market for a new car, you’ll be hard-pressed to find a model without one or more of these features. 

 

Using a combination of video cameras, lidar, radar, and ultrasonic sensors, these systems fall along a spectrum ranging from passive warnings to active vehicle control. But ADAS are just that: driver assistance systems, meaning the driver must still remain attentive and is responsible for operating the vehicle safely.

 

The most common ADAS include:

  • Forward Collision Warning (FCW) & Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB): Alerts the driver to slowed or stopped obstacles ahead and automatically applies the brakes if the driver fails to react in time.
  • Lane Departure Warning (LDW) & Lane Keeping Assist (LKA): Tracks painted road lines, alerting the driver if the car drifts and providing gentle steering inputs to center the vehicle.
  • Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC): Uses forward sensors to maintain a pre-set following distance, matching the speed of traffic ahead.
  • Blind Spot Detection (BSD) & Rear Cross-Traffic Alert (RCTA): Uses rear-facing sensors to light up a warning icon in your side mirrors if a vehicle is traveling in your blind spot during a lane change and detects crossing traffic when backing up.
  • Direct Driver Monitoring Systems (DDMS): Uses infrared cabin cameras to track head position and eye gaze, chiming or slowing the vehicle if the driver looks away from the road for more than a few seconds.
  • Rearview Camera & Parking Assist: Displays a video feed of behind the vehicle, applying the brakes if it detects an obstacle, and uses sonar or sensors to assist with parallel or backup parking maneuvers. 
  • Active Driving Assistance (Level 2 Systems): Bundles ACC and lane-centering to steer, accelerate, and brake semi-autonomously under specific highway or stop-and-go conditions.

Despite slick marketing terms, even systems like Tesla’s Autopilot, GM’s Super Cruise, or Nissan’s ProPILOT, are not self-driving systems. By law and engineering design, they are Level 2 driver-assist platforms. The human behind the wheel remains legally responsible for monitoring the road and being prepared to intervene at a moment’s notice.

Can Driver-Assistance Technology Actually Cause an Accident?

With all of these features designed to prevent accidents, is it possible that they can actually contribute to the accident instead? Despite all of the technological advancements to date, the systems are nowhere near perfect and are no substitute for an attentive driver. Risks and pitfalls of overreliance on technology include:

  1. Phantom braking: A notorious pitfall where a vehicle’s forward collision sensors can mistake an overhead shadow, highway sign, bridge seam, or paved-over pothole for a physical barrier, causing the car to suddenly slam on the brakes at highway speeds and triggering rear-end chain reactions.
  2. Environmental blindness: Rain, heavy snow, thick fog, salt spray, or direct low-angle sunlight can blind cameras and radar. A thin layer of road grime or dead insects over a sensor can disable critical safety features without warning. 
  3. Misread road markings: Lane-keeping systems can be confused by faded paint, complex construction shifts, temporary lane shifts, rain glare, or tar patches on asphalt, causing the vehicle to follow an obsolete line into oncoming traffic or a highway barrier. 
  4. Failure to detect stationary or unusual hazards: Many forward-facing systems excel at tracking moving vehicles, but struggle with stationary barriers, emergency response vehicles parked on shoulders, objects such as a lamppost or mailbox, or pedestrians and cyclists moving at slower speeds. Similarly, some systems occasionally fail to recognize unconventional hazards, like a strangely shaped delivery truck or a person carrying a large object. None of them are as good as you might like when you’re driving at full speed and the vehicle ahead of you changes lanes suddenly to reveal a stationary object in your path.
  5. Computer malfunctions: Because these systems are interconnected, a fault in a single minor sensor (like a rear bumper radar) can sometimes trigger a cascade of warning lights, completely disabling unrelated features. 
  6. Difficulty regaining control: Some automated driving systems can make it difficult for drivers to regain control quickly when the vehicle brakes, accelerates, or steers unexpectedly. A driver may have to apply enough steering force to override the system or wait for automatic braking to release before accelerating again. Even an attentive driver may have only a fraction of a second to recognize the problem and avoid a collision.

Does Driver-Assistance Technology Make Drivers Complacent?

One of the less obvious dangers of ADAS is that they can lull drivers into a false sense of security. When a vehicle routinely handles simple steering, braking, and acceleration, it’s easy to become overly reliant on the technology and assume the car will respond appropriately to whatever happens on the road. 

This phenomenon, known as automation complacency, can cause drivers to become less attentive to their surroundings and slower to recognize developing hazards. Rather than actively monitoring traffic and road conditions, they may have the false impression that the vehicle is handling everything on their behalf. Consumer Reports writes that “When a system is controlling a car’s speed and steering, there’s a risk that its driver might feel more free to pick up a cell phone, eat a messy burger, or engage in other reckless, distracting behavior.”

The danger becomes particularly apparent when the system encounters something it can’t handle, such as unexpected road construction, confusing lane markings, or a stopped emergency vehicle. If the technology suddenly miscalculates or makes an incorrect maneuver, a distracted or disengaged driver may not be able to regain situational awareness quickly enough to avert disaster.

Manufacturers also play a role in managing driver expectations of what their vehicle can do. Marketing that overstates a system’s capabilities, along with inadequate safeguards against foreseeable misuse, can encourage drivers to place more trust in the technology than it deserves. We’ll say it again: no matter how sophisticated the technology, drivers must remain attentive and prepared to intervene. 

Tesla Is Just One Example

Tesla has faced several high-profile lawsuits involving fatal crashes and its Autopilot driver-assistance technology, including a $243 million jury verdict in 2025. These cases have raised important questions not only about the technology’s limitations, but also about how manufacturers market its capabilities. In this case, the jury assigned 33% of the responsibility to Tesla and 67% to the driver, showing that both driver negligence and vehicle technology can become central issues in determining liability.

Despite its name, Tesla’s Autopilot is a Level 2 driver-assistance system, meaning drivers must still remain attentive and in control of their vehicles. US News wrote in June 2026 that “the system isn’t, and never was, the ‘full self-driving’ technology that Tesla marketed, promised and still implies.” Critics argue that names like Autopilot, coupled with misleading advertising that shows hands-free imagery, can give consumers a false sense of what the technology can safely do. 

While manufacturers emphasize that drivers must remain alert, these cases illustrate why responsibility for an accident could extend beyond the person behind the wheel, particularly when the technology itself or the manufacturer’s representations about its capabilities contributed to the crash.

Does Driver-Assistance Technology Impact a Driver’s Responsibility?

With respect to ADAS, two things can be true at the same time:

  • Drivers are legally required to pay attention. Automakers place clear warnings in owner’s manuals reminding operators to keep hands on the wheel and eyes on the road.
  • Vehicles must not behave unpredictably. A vehicle that abruptly swerves or locks up its brakes can generate an emergency so sudden that even an attentive driver has no realistic opportunity to avoid a collision.

An accident involving driver-assistance technology might be more complicated than it first appears, and a thorough investigation can make all the difference in identifying who is responsible. When an automated system fails or triggers an evasive maneuver without cause, liability does not necessarily stop with the driver. If software logic was flawed, if sensors were prone to known defects, or if marketing representations misled drivers into believing the vehicle was fully self-driving, grounds may also exist for a product liability or wrongful death claim against the automaker.

Holding Multiple Parties Accountable

A driver’s negligence and an automotive product defect are not mutually exclusive. In states operating under comparative fault and joint and several liability rules (such as Massachusetts), an injured party can name both the at-fault driver and the vehicle manufacturer in a lawsuit.

Identifying all potentially responsible parties becomes critical in catastrophic injury or wrongful death cases, where an individual driver’s personal auto insurance policy limits fall far short of covering lifetime medical care and damages. Seeking the advice of experienced legal counsel is key to building a strong case.

How Can Electronic Evidence Reveal What Really Caused an Accident?

In an ADAS-related collision, physical evidence like skid marks and vehicle damage tells only half the story. Most modern vehicles maintain event data recorders (EDRs) and proprietary manufacturer telematics that document the split-second reality of a crash. 

The data doesn’t lie.

Sometimes the critical data lies deep within the manufacturer’s own systems, requiring dogged investigation. An attorney handling an ADAS claim must secure and analyze vehicle data snapshots to answer critical technical questions such as:

  • Was an automated driving or driver-assistance feature active at the moment of impact?
  • Did the vehicle brake, steer, or accelerate on its own, or did the driver initiate the action?
  • Did the system issue an alert, sound a handover warning, or abruptly disengage before the crash?
  • Did the driver attempt to override the system with steering or brake inputs?
  • Can the vehicle software prove or disprove a driver’s claim that “the car made me do it”?

The initial facts may suggest a straightforward accident, but further investigation can reveal additional parties, insurance coverage, or other sources of potential recovery. 

What Should You Do if You Suspect Driver-Assistance Technology Contributed to Your Accident?

Driver-assistance systems are engineered to protect us, but when flawed programming or marketing disconnects meet unpredictable highway environments, they can fail spectacularly. Investigating these accidents requires specialized legal and technical expertise to unravel complex electronic evidence, determine how the vehicle’s systems operated in the moments leading up to the crash, and establish whether and how a technological failure contributed to the collision. 

If you or a loved one has been seriously hurt in an automobile accident where the failure of an ADAS may have contributed to your injuries:

  1. Preserve the Vehicle: Before authorizing repairs or disposing of a vehicle, consult an attorney about preserving potentially relevant electronic and physical evidence. Onboard computers hold valuable data required to evaluate the incident.
  2. Protect Digital Telematics: Some vehicles record information about braking, steering, driver inputs, and system activity. Reach out to legal counsel as soon as possible to prevent important data from being overwritten or deleted.
  3. Document Conditions: Photographs of road conditions, lane markings, construction zones, weather, and surrounding traffic may help investigators understand whether environmental conditions affected the vehicle’s driver-assistance systems.

With more than 30 years of experience in personal injury law, Parker Scheer has the legal and technical expertise necessary to handle even the most complex automobile and trucking accidents. Our results speak for themselves.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a driver be held responsible if their car’s automatic braking causes an accident?

Yes. Drivers generally remain responsible for operating their vehicles safely, even when automatic braking or other assistance features are activated. However, if a defective braking system contributed to the collision, the manufacturer may also bear responsibility. Determining liability depends on the circumstances of the accident.

Can electronic vehicle data prove that a driver-assistance system malfunctioned?

Potentially. Depending on the vehicle and the information recorded, electronic data may show whether an assistance feature was activated, how the vehicle responded, and whether the driver attempted to intervene. Technical analysis can help establish whether a system malfunction contributed to the crash.

Can I pursue a claim against both the driver and the vehicle manufacturer in Massachusetts?

Yes. If a driver’s negligence and a defective vehicle system both contributed to an accident, an injured person might have grounds to pursue claims against multiple parties. The applicable liability rules and available evidence will determine how responsibility is allocated.

Primary Sidebar

CALL US 7 DAYS 617-886-0500

Injured? Contact Our Offices For A Free Consultation

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Sort by Category

  • Bicycle Accidents
  • Car Accidents
  • College Students
  • Community Outreach
  • Criminal Defense News
  • Dog Bite
  • Employment Law
  • Firm News
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Motor Vehicle Accidents
  • Personal Injury
  • Product Liability
  • Uncategorized

Practice Areas

  • Personal Injury
  • Business Law & Litigation
  • Employment Law

View All Practice Areas

Client Testimonials

M. S. 

I went to Parker and Scheer two years ago when I was hit riding my bicycle in NYC. This was a difficult and helpless time. Surgery was required and I didn’t have health insurance. I had never been through anything like this before and didn’t know where to turn...

Read More
Andrea K.

Eric Parker saw the potential in my case and explored it in detail with patience and professionalism. He and his team achieved the outcome I was hoping for, and I can recommend Parker Scheer with absolute confidence.

Read More
T.G.

I was referred to Parker|Scheer after my daughter was seriously injured in a car accident in November 2010. Deb and the firm of Parker|Scheer were nothing short of spectacular. If I ever need legal representation again, I would use them in a minute.

Read More
Client Review on Avvo.

Great Lawyer – Attorney Tofani was referred to me through friends and was highly recommended. I found myself in a tough situation with no prior criminal history and not sure what to expect. Attorney Tofani was kind, professional and experienced in the system.

Read More
A.Q.

I have worked with Eric Parker and Barry Scheer for over a over 15 years. I have recommended them to friends and family without disappointment. When you know that you have someone you can call on a moments notice, for any legal matter, it is a comfort...

Read More
Matt S.

My case was very unique. Through his hard work and excellent skills, Attorney Tofani achieved the bestpossible outcome. I highly recommend Attorney Tofani.

Read More

View All Testimonials

Footer

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • Meet Our Boston Attorneys
  • Product Recalls
  • Leave Us a Review

Connect With Us




BOSTON OFFICE

1 Center Plaza, Suite 420, Boston, MA 02108

PHONE : (617) 886-0500

NYC OFFICE

445 Park Ave. Floor 9 New York, NY 10022

PHONE : (212) 897-2223

 

NEW HAMPSHIRE OFFICE

170 Commerce Way, Suite 200, Portsmouth, NH 03801

PHONE : (603) 507-6627

 

© 2026 Parker Scheer LLP. All rights reserved | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service